Coway Mighty vs. Blueair Blue Pure Air Purifiers - ConsumerReports.org

Posted: 27 Nov 2019 03:39 PM PST

CR's Dave Trezza and his team of engineers test each air purifier in a sealed chamber, into which they inject smoke and dust particles. A particle counter measures the change in particle concentration as the air purifier runs for 15 minutes on the highest speed, and then again at a lower speed. Our engineers also measure noise levels while the air purifier is in use from 4 feet away. Here's the breakdown of how each model performs.

Particle Reduction and Noise at High Speed
The Blueair aces our particle reduction test on high speed, meaning it effectively clears the air in the room of both large (dust) and small (smoke) particles quickly. The Coway scores slightly lower than the Blueair for particle reduction, meaning there were more particles left floating in the air after 15 minutes.

Both models rate Fair for noise at high speed, which is on par with the sound of rainfall. But since the Blueair clears the room a bit better, it wins this test.

Particle Reduction and Noise at Low Speed
The low-speed setting is where we see the biggest difference in performance between the two models. The Blueair once again earns an Excellent rating for clearing the air in the room of particles. The Coway is no match here: It removes far fewer particles at this speed than the Blueair, earning a Fair rating in this test.

As for how loud these models are while operating at low speed, the Coway does better than the Blueair, earning a Very Good rating compared with Blueair's Good rating, but that lead is moot since the Coway does a poor job of cleaning the air at this setting. The Blueair gains major ground ahead of the Coway in this test.

Annual Cost to Operate and Maintain
In order to maintain clean indoor air, purifiers should operate 24 hours a day. We estimate it will cost $52 for the electricity needed to run the Blueair all day (based on an average of high and low speeds). The filter needs to be changed about every six months at $70 a pop, so the total annual cost to maintain and operate the Blueair is $192.

The Coway makes a smaller dent in the electric bill: $44 a year. Plus, its HEPA filter is good for one year (the carbon filters need to be replaced every six months). Replacement filters for an entire year come out to $43, making the total annual cost $87. "That's really low," says Trezza. "The average annual cost for our top-rated models is about $200." As long as you run it on the high-speed setting and don't mind some din in the room, the Coway can save you some major bucks in the long run. It wins this comparison by over $100 annually.

Ease of Use
The Coway scores a Very Good rating for ease of use while the Blueair gets a middle-of-the-road Good rating because of a couple of factors: It doesn't have a carrying handle or wheels, making it a little more cumbersome to move from room to room, and it has only one unlabeled button that you push multiple times to control power and speed settings. Some users may appreciate the minimalist look, while others may find it confusing to operate. The Coway is a nose ahead of the Blueair in this assessment.

Buying an Air Purifier? Here's What You Need to Know - Tom's Guide

Posted: 11 Nov 2019 12:00 AM PST

There are dozens of indoor air purifiers to choose from, but many manufacturers offer only vague explanations for how their products work, or make outlandish health claims. The truth is that air purifiers aren't a panacea for improving indoor air quality, but the right one may still help you breathe a little better.

So how can you tell which one is right for you? We've put together a guide to alleviate the confusion and help you pick the best air purifier for your home size and budget.

Quick tips

Figure out where you want to place your purifier so you can choose the right size for your space.
Look for a purifier that's good at filtering out pollutants specific to your home or health needs (removing pet dander or cigarette smoke, for example).
Compare CADR ratings, which show how effectively a purifier filters specific pollutants.
Choose a device that uses a HEPA filter, the gold standard for indoor air purifiers.
Look at noise levels (listed in decibels) in product specs. Depending on where you're using your air purifier, you may want a quieter device.
Calculate ongoing maintenance and electricity costs so you can budget beyond your initial purchase.
Skip the bonus features, such as app integration, unless money is no object.

Room size

The first step to filtering out air purifiers (no pun intended) is figuring out how much space you want your device to clean. Small desktop devices aren't effective in large living spaces, while larger, heavy-duty purifiers may be overkill in your kid's bedroom.

One way to find the best fit is to look at "air changes per hour." This metric may be included in your purifier's specs. It can help you understand how filtration works in practice, as a smaller purifier could turn over the air in a 350-square-foot room eight times in an hour but manage just four air changes per hour in a 700-square-foot room.

You can also compare clean air delivery rates (CADR), which we'll get into below.

If you're not sure how much space you need to clean, it's probably better to get a larger purifier than what you think you'll need, as long as it's within your budget.

Pollutant types

Some purifiers are better at filtering out certain types of pollutants than others. If your main concern is cigarette smoke, for example, you may need a different device than someone who lives with a zoo's worth of pets.

Coway Airmega 400 (Image credit: Conway)

Air purifiers are rated based on how well they filter different pollutant sizes. While most purifiers are similar across the board, some are slightly more effective at catching dust and dander than smoke (or vice versa). If odors are a concern, you'll want to find a purifier that has an activated carbon filter, such as the Coway Airmega 400.

If you're aiming for general air-quality improvement, look for a purifier, such as the Coway AP-1512HH Mighty, that performs well across the board.

CADR rating

Most air purifiers are labeled with a clean air delivery rate (CADR), a metric developed by the Association of Home Appliance Manufacturers that helps consumers understand how effective a device is at filtering various particles in a specific room size.

IQAir HealthPro Plus (Image credit: IQAir)

For example, a CADR of 200 for pollen means that the purifier can reduce the pollen concentration at the equivalent of adding 200 cubic feet of fresh air per minute. In general, the higher the number, the more particles the purifier can remove and the larger the room the device can reasonably be expected to clean.

The Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) has guidelines for minimum CADR ratings by room size:

Area (square feet)	100	200	300	400	500	600
Minimum CADR (cubic feet per minute)	60	130	195	260	325	390

Some devices have a single CADR number, while others have different ratings for smoke (and similarly small particles), dust and pollen (and similarly large particles). The EPA cautions that for a typical room size, most purifiers don't have CADR ratings high enough to effectively remove large pollutants like dust mites and cockroach-related allergens.

MORE: 5 Reasons You Need an Air Purifier

Also, keep in mind that a device's CADR rating reflects the best-case scenario. These numbers are determined in controlled testing environments. Variables in your home, such as drafts or dampness, may prevent your purifier from hitting its optimal rating.

Finally, not every purifier is tested using the CADR system. The manufacturer of the IQAir HealthPro Plus, one of our recommended models, does not submit the device for AHAM testing. Read independent reviews to get an idea of how well a device works.

Filter types

The air purifiers we recommend use mechanical filtration, meaning they physically trap the pollutants that pass through them. Your air purifier likely has at least two filters: a prefilter, which catches large particles like pet hair, and the main filter, which nabs smaller pollutants.

Pure Enrichment PureZone 3-in-1 (Image credit: PureZone)

There's not much of a difference between prefilters. A few are washable (or vacuumable), while others are disposable. The latter may cost you a bit more in the long run, but otherwise, there's not much to compare.

What really matters is your device's main filter. In general, you'll want to look for a purifier that uses a high-efficiency particulate air (HEPA) filter, the standard recommended by the EPA and the American Lung Association.

MORE: How Do Air Purifiers Work?

HEPA filters trap 99.97% of particles that are 0.3 microns or larger in size and almost all particles that are smaller. To put that in perspective, the average human eye can see objects that are around 70 microns in size and may be able to distinguish light-scattering airborne particles as small as 10 microns in size.

You may find devices that advertise "HEPA-type" filters but that aren't actually rated to meet a HEPA filtration level. Since individual HEPA filters aren't tested, it's hard to say that merely HEPA-type filters will always perform more poorly. But your best bet is to go with a purifier that says it uses HEPA or "True" HEPA filters, which amount to the same thing.

Blueair Blue Pure 411 (Image credit: Blueair)

Some purifiers have additional filters, often made of activated carbon, that trap gases, volatile organic compounds (VOCs) and odor compounds. These extra filters can be helpful if you live with a smoker or have pets, but they are designed to absorb only a limited number of specific compounds and have to be changed regularly to be effective.

Some air purifiers advertise filtration processes that rely on ionizers or UV light. The effectiveness of these devices isn't well demonstrated. They may also produce ozone, which is a lung irritant that could make any breathing-related problems worse rather than better.

The Coway AP-1512HH Mighty has an ionizer that can be switched off. The Blueair Blue Pure 211+ and Blueair Blue Pure 411 have ionizers built right into their proprietary HEPASilent filters, but their manufacturer says they produce very little ozone. The Pure Enrichment PureZone 3-in-1 True HEPA Air Purifier has a UV light.

Noise

Most purifiers have internal fans that pull air through a series of filters. Some fans are practically silent, especially on low settings. Others make a humming sound as you turn them up. If you're using your purifier in a bedroom or baby's room, for example, you may want to choose a device that's relatively quiet, even at higher speeds.

Austin Air HealthMate HM400 (Image credit: Austin)

You'll find noise level ranges measured in decibels in your device's specs. We've seen air purifiers, such as the Blueair Blue Pure 411, rated as low as 17 dB (similar to rustling leaves), but others, such as the Austin Air HealthMate HM400, can reach noise levels of more than 60 dB (akin to an AC unit 100 feet away).

Portability

Some air purifiers are lighter and more mobile than others. The smallest ones sit on a desk or shelf and are easily moved from room to room.

Blueair Blue Pure 211+ (Image credit: Blueair)

The larger and heavier ones are best kept stationary, though some come with casters for portability. If you want to use your purifier in your home office during the day, your living room in the evening and your bedroom overnight, look for a smaller device or one that rolls.

As we've mentioned, the size of a purifier is loosely correlated to the size of the room it can effectively clean, so the best option for your nursery probably won't be the right choice for a family room that's three or four times larger. You'll want to find a happy medium between size and portability if you plan to have one purifier cover your whole home.

Maintenance costs

The up-front cost of your air purifier matters if you're on a budget, but don't assume you're done paying for the device once you have set it up in your home. You'll have to periodically replace the filters on an ongoing basis.

Coway AP-1512HH Mighty (Image credit: Coway)

Costs vary from machine to machine: Some have very expensive filters that last for years, while others use cheap filters that have to be changed frequently. Plus, while some of the prefilters are washable, the HEPA filters themselves are disposable and must be entirely replaced.

Before you buy an air purifier, calculate the cost per year to maintain it, and compare that cost to those of any other air-purification device you might be considering.

Energy efficiency

Air purifiers are most effective when they're on almost constantly, so you'll also want to factor in electricity costs. Some of the devices we recommend are Energy Star-certified, but each pulls varying amounts of power depending on the fan speed you're using.

Levoit LV-H132 (Image credit: Levoit)

Smaller purifiers, like the Levoit LV-H132, generally use less energy, but they clean much smaller spaces. On the flip side, devices that are rated for larger rooms and that have higher fan speeds, such as the Coway Airmega 400, tend to draw more energy.

A few purifiers have "eco" modes that power down the devices and place them on standby when their sensors no longer detect airborne pollutants.

MORE: Best Air Purifiers: Clean Air for Allergies, Pets and Mold

You can usually find your purifier's estimated energy usage in the product specs. We've seen devices that supposedly draw as little as 1.5 watts on low, as well as power-hungry ones that draw more than 200 watts on high. You may not even notice the impact of the former on your electricity bill, but the latter could add up.

Bonus features

Some purifiers come with additional features:

Filter indicator light
Dimming and display shut-off options
Programmable timer
Remote
Smart functions (digital assistant and/or app integration)

These extras may add a little bit of convenience, but they're probably not worth paying significantly more to get. For an example of what they can do, with one of these features, you can set a calendar reminder to change your filter based on your device's maintenance schedule.

Our top air purifier pick, the Coway AP-1512HH Mighty, includes several of these nice-to-have features and is reasonably priced. But in general, we'd recommend prioritizing other factors if your budget is a concern.

Bottom line

There is no single air purifier that's right for everyone. When you're shopping for a purifier, always look first at a device's CADR ratings and filter types to get an idea of how effective the purifier will be for your specific needs.

Once you've identified a purifier that offers the best filtration for common pollutants in your home and that is the right size for your space, evaluate secondary features like noise levels and portability. Also make sure energy and ongoing maintenance costs are within your budget.

Search This Blog

Air Purifier Mold